What is Phonics Instruction?

Phonics instruction teaches children the relationship between letters (graphemes) and sounds (phonemes). It is a methodical approach that helps learners understand how to decode words by sounding them out, which is essential for reading and spelling. Phonics instruction typically includes teaching the following elements:

Alphabetic Principle: Understanding that letters and letter patterns represent the sounds of spoken language.

Phonemic Awareness: Recognizing and manipulating phonemes, the smallest units of sound.

Letter-Sound Correspondence: Learning which sounds correspond to which letters or groups of letters.

Blending: Combining individual sounds to form words.

Segmenting: Breaking down words into their individual sounds.

Decoding: Using knowledge of letter-sound relationships to read unfamiliar words.

Phonics instruction can be delivered through various approaches, including synthetic phonics (teaching how to convert letters into sounds and blend them to form words) and analytic phonics (analyzing whole words to detect phonetic patterns and then applying them to new words).

The Importance of Phonics Instruction

The National Reading Panel's 2000 report highlighted phonics instruction as one of the five critical components of effective reading instruction, alongside phonemic awareness, fluency, vocabulary, and text comprehension. Here’s why phonics instruction is so important:

Foundation for Reading and Spelling

Phonics instruction provides the foundational skills necessary for reading and spelling. Understanding the relationship between letters and sounds enables children to decode new words, an essential skill for fluent reading.

Improves Word Recognition

By learning phonics, children can recognize familiar words quickly and accurately. This automatic word recognition is crucial for reading fluency and comprehension, as it allows children to focus on the meaning of the text rather than on decoding individual words.

Enhances Reading Comprehension

Phonics instruction supports reading comprehension by enabling children to read words effortlessly. When children can decode words automatically, they can dedicate more cognitive resources to understanding and interpreting the text.

Supports Spelling Skills

Phonics instruction helps children understand the predictable patterns of spelling in English. This knowledge is essential for writing and spelling new words accurately.

Helps Struggling Readers

Research has shown that systematic phonics instruction is particularly beneficial for struggling readers and those with reading disabilities. It provides a structured approach that can help these children develop the skills they need to become proficient readers.

Current Research on Phonics Instruction

Since the publication of the NRP Report, further research has continued to support the importance of phonics instruction in reading development. Key findings from recent studies include:

Systematic Phonics Instruction

Systematic phonics instruction, where letter-sound relationships are taught in an organized and sequential manner, is more effective than non-systematic or incidental phonics instruction. This approach ensures that all essential phonics skills are covered and that children have a solid foundation for reading.

Long-Term Benefits

Longitudinal studies have demonstrated the long-term benefits of early phonics instruction. Children who receive systematic phonics instruction in the early grades show better reading outcomes in later years compared to those who do not receive such instruction.

Phonics and Socioeconomic Status

Research indicates that phonics instruction can help close the reading achievement gap associated with socioeconomic status. Children from low-income families who receive systematic phonics instruction show significant improvements in reading skills, highlighting the importance of equitable access to effective reading instruction.

Neuroscientific Evidence

Advances in neuroscience have provided insights into how phonics instruction affects the brain. Functional MRI studies show that phonics instruction activates specific brain areas associated with reading and language processing, leading to improved reading skills.

Practical Strategies for Effective Phonics Instruction

To maximize the effectiveness of phonics instruction, educators should incorporate evidence-based strategies into their teaching practices. Here are some practical tips:

Explicit and Systematic Instruction

Provide explicit, systematic instruction in phonics. This involves teaching letter-sound relationships in a planned, sequential order, ensuring that children learn the necessary skills to decode words effectively.

Multisensory Techniques

Use multisensory techniques to engage children and reinforce learning. This can include activities that involve visual, auditory, and kinesthetic elements, such as using letter tiles, writing in sand, or tracing letters.

Integrate Phonics with Reading and Writing

Integrate phonics instruction with reading and writing activities. This helps children see the practical application of phonics skills and reinforces their learning. For example, incorporate phonics practice into guided reading sessions and writing exercises.

Differentiate Instruction

Differentiate phonics instruction to meet the diverse needs of learners. Provide additional support and practice for struggling readers, and challenge advanced readers with more complex phonics tasks.

Frequent Practice and Review

Provide frequent practice and review of phonics skills to ensure mastery. Repetition and reinforcement help solidify children’s understanding and improve their ability to apply phonics skills in reading and writing.

Use of Technology

Incorporate technology to enhance phonics instruction. Educational software, apps, and online resources can provide interactive and engaging phonics practice for children.

Case Study: Effective Phonics Instruction in Action

To illustrate the practical application of these strategies, let’s look at a case study from a first-grade classroom.

Classroom Context:

Ms. Garcia is a first-grade teacher who has implemented a comprehensive phonics program in her classroom. She uses a systematic and explicit approach to teach phonics, incorporating various multisensory activities and integrating phonics with reading and writing.

Implementation:

Daily Phonics Lessons: Ms. Garcia begins each day with a 20-minute phonics lesson, focusing on a specific letter-sound relationship. She uses visual aids, such as letter cards and charts, to introduce the new sound and model how to blend and segment words.

Multisensory Activities: During the lesson, Ms. Garcia incorporates multisensory activities, such as having students use letter tiles to build words, trace letters in sand, and practice writing words on whiteboards.

Guided Reading: Ms. Garcia integrates phonics instruction with guided reading sessions. She selects leveled books that reinforce the phonics skills being taught and provides opportunities for students to apply their phonics knowledge while reading.

Writing Practice: Students also engage in writing activities that reinforce phonics skills. For example, they might write sentences or short stories using words that include the targeted phonics patterns.

Differentiation: Ms. Garcia differentiates her instruction by providing additional support to struggling readers through small-group instruction and individualized practice. She also challenges advanced readers with more complex phonics tasks and reading materials.

Technology Integration: Ms. Garcia uses educational software and apps that provide interactive phonics practice. Students have access to these resources during literacy centers and independent work time.

Outcomes:

By the end of the school year, Ms. Garcia’s students demonstrate significant improvement in their phonics skills. They can decode unfamiliar words with greater ease, read more fluently, and show better reading comprehension. Ms. Garcia’s systematic and engaging approach to phonics instruction has helped her students build a strong foundation for reading success.

Phonics instruction is a vital component of early reading development, as highlighted by the National Reading Panel and supported by ongoing research. It provides the foundational skills necessary for decoding, word recognition, spelling, and reading comprehension. Effective phonics instruction, delivered through explicit, systematic, and engaging methods, can significantly improve children’s reading outcomes.

Educators play a crucial role in providing effective phonics instruction. By incorporating evidence-based strategies and differentiating instruction to meet the diverse needs of learners, they can help ensure that all children develop the skills necessary for reading success. As research continues to evolve, the importance of phonics instruction remains clear, underscoring its role as a cornerstone of literacy education.

References

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2000). Report of the National Reading Panel: Teaching Children to Read: An Evidence-Based Assessment of the Scientific Research Literature on Reading and Its Implications for Reading Instruction. U.S. Government Printing Office.

Ehri, L. C., Nunes, S. R., Willows, D. M., Schuster, B. V., Yaghoub-Zadeh, Z., & Shanahan, T. (2001). Phonics instruction helps children learn to read: Evidence from the National Reading Panel's meta-analysis. Reading Research Quarterly, 36(3), 250-287.

Bowers, J. S. (2020). Reconsidering the evidence that systematic phonics is more effective than alternative methods of reading instruction. Educational Psychology Review, 32(3), 681-705.

Castles, A., Rastle, K., & Nation, K. (2018). Ending the reading wars: Reading acquisition from novice to expert. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 19(1), 5-51.

Kilpatrick, D. A. (2015). Essentials of Assessing, Preventing, and Overcoming Reading Difficulties. Wiley.

Phonemic awareness is a critical component of early reading development, serving as the foundation for proficient reading skills. This concept was extensively explored in the National Reading Panel (NRP) Report, which emphasized its significance in the broader context of literacy education.

What is Phonemic Awareness?

Phonemic awareness is the ability to hear, identify, and manipulate individual sounds—phonemes—in spoken words. It is a subcategory of phonological awareness, which includes a range of skills involving the recognition and manipulation of sounds at different levels (words, syllables, onset-rime, and phonemes). Phonemic awareness focuses specifically on the smallest units of sound that can change the meaning of words. For example, changing the first phoneme in the word "cat" from /k/ to /h/ transforms it into "hat."

Skills associated with phonemic awareness include:

• Phoneme Isolation: Recognizing individual sounds in words (e.g., identifying the first sound in "dog" as /d/).
• Phoneme Identity: Recognizing the common sound in different words (e.g., identifying /b/ in "bat," "ball," and "boy").
• Phoneme Categorization: Identifying the odd sound out in a set of words (e.g., "bat," "ball," "rug").
• Phoneme Blending: Combining individual sounds to form a word (e.g., /b/, /a/, /t/ to form "bat").
• Phoneme Segmentation: Breaking a word into its individual sounds (e.g., "cat" into /k/, /æ/, /t/).
• Phoneme Deletion: Recognizing the word that remains when a phoneme is removed (e.g., removing /s/ from "smile" to get "mile").

The Importance of Phonemic Awareness

The National Reading Panel Report highlighted phonemic awareness as a crucial predictor of later reading success. Here's why phonemic awareness is so important:

• Foundation for Reading and Spelling: Phonemic awareness provides the foundation for understanding the alphabetic principle—the idea that letters and letter patterns represent the sounds of spoken language. This understanding is essential for decoding (reading) and encoding (spelling) words.
• Predictive of Future Reading Success: Research shows that children with strong phonemic awareness skills are more likely to become proficient readers. Conversely, children who struggle with phonemic awareness are at a higher risk for reading difficulties.
• Improves Word Recognition: Phonemic awareness helps children develop efficient word recognition skills. By being able to break words into phonemes and blend phonemes to form words, children can more easily recognize and read unfamiliar words.
• Supports Reading Comprehension: Good phonemic awareness skills lead to better word recognition, which in turn frees up cognitive resources for comprehension. When children can quickly and accurately recognize words, they can focus more on understanding the text's meaning.

Current Research on Phonemic Awareness

Since the publication of the NRP Report, further research has continued to support the importance of phonemic awareness in reading development. Key findings from recent studies include:

• Longitudinal Studies: Longitudinal studies have reinforced that early phonemic awareness is a strong predictor of later reading achievement. Children who enter school with well-developed phonemic awareness are more likely to experience reading success throughout their academic careers.
• Neuroscientific Research: Advances in neuroscience have shown that phonemic awareness activates specific areas of the brain associated with reading and language processing. Functional MRI studies reveal that successful reading interventions, which include phonemic awareness training, can lead to changes in brain activity patterns, indicating improved reading skills.
• Interventions for Struggling Readers: Effective reading interventions for struggling readers often include a significant focus on phonemic awareness. Studies have shown that targeted phonemic awareness instruction can help remediate reading difficulties and improve overall reading achievement.
• Impact of Early Intervention: Research highlights the importance of early intervention in phonemic awareness. Interventions provided in preschool and early elementary school are more effective than those provided later, emphasizing the need for early identification and support for children at risk of reading difficulties.

Practical Strategies for Teaching Phonemic Awareness

Given the importance of phonemic awareness, educators and parents must incorporate effective strategies for developing these skills in young learners. Here are some evidence-based practices:

• Explicit Instruction: Provide explicit, systematic instruction in phonemic awareness. This involves directly teaching children about phonemes and how to manipulate them through various activities.
• Use of Manipulatives: Use physical manipulatives, such as letter tiles or counters, to help children visualize and manipulate sounds. This hands-on approach can make abstract concepts more concrete and understandable.
• Incorporate Fun Activities: Incorporate games and playful activities that promote phonemic awareness, such as rhyming games, sound matching, and phoneme substitution. Making learning fun can engage children and reinforce skills.
• Modeling and Scaffolding: Model phonemic awareness tasks and provide scaffolding to support children as they practice. Gradually reduce support as children become more proficient.
• Integrate with Other Literacy Activities: Integrate phonemic awareness activities with other literacy instruction, such as reading aloud, shared reading, and writing. This integration helps children make connections between phonemic awareness and other aspects of literacy.
• Ongoing Assessment: Regularly assess children’s phonemic awareness skills to monitor progress and identify those who may need additional support. Use both formal and informal assessment tools to gather data on student performance.

Case Study: Effective Phonemic Awareness Instruction

To illustrate the practical application of these strategies, let’s look at a case study from a kindergarten classroom.

Classroom Context:

Ms. Johnson is a kindergarten teacher who has implemented a comprehensive phonemic awareness program in her classroom. She begins each day with a 15-minute phonemic awareness session, focusing on a specific skill, such as phoneme segmentation or blending.

Implementation:

Warm-Up Activity: Ms. Johnson starts with a warm-up activity, such as a rhyming game, to engage students and prepare them for the lesson.

Explicit Instruction: She then provides explicit instruction on the day’s focus skill, using visual aids and modeling the task.

Guided Practice: Students engage in guided practice with Ms. Johnson’s support, using manipulatives to segment and blend phonemes.

Independent Practice: Students then practice independently or in small groups, with activities such as sorting pictures based on initial sounds or playing sound-matching games.

Integration: Ms. Johnson integrates phonemic awareness into other literacy activities, such as shared reading. She pauses during read-alouds to highlight phonemes and engage students in phonemic tasks related to the text.

Assessment: Ms. Johnson uses both observational assessments and formal tools to monitor student progress. She adjusts her instruction based on assessment data, providing additional support to students who need it.

Outcomes: By the end of the school year, Ms. Johnson’s students show significant improvement in their phonemic awareness skills. They demonstrate strong word recognition abilities and are well-prepared for first-grade reading instruction. Ms. Johnson’s systematic and engaging approach to phonemic awareness has laid a solid foundation for her students’ future reading success.

Phonemic awareness is a vital component of early reading development, as highlighted by the National Reading Panel and supported by ongoing research. It serves as the foundation for decoding, word recognition, and reading comprehension. Effective phonemic awareness instruction, provided through explicit, systematic, and engaging activities, can significantly improve children’s reading outcomes.

Everyone plays a crucial role in fostering phonemic awareness in young learners. By incorporating evidence-based strategies and providing early intervention, they can help ensure that all children develop the skills necessary for reading success. As research continues to evolve, the importance of phonemic awareness remains clear, underscoring its role as a cornerstone of literacy education.

References

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2000). Report of the National Reading Panel: Teaching Children to Read: An Evidence-Based Assessment of the Scientific Research Literature on Reading and Its Implications for Reading Instruction. U.S. Government Printing Office.

Ehri, L. C., Nunes, S. R., Willows, D. M., Schuster, B. V., Yaghoub-Zadeh, Z., & Shanahan, T. (2001). Phonemic awareness instruction helps children learn to read: Evidence from the National Reading Panel's meta-analysis. Reading Research Quarterly, 36(3), 250-287.

Kilpatrick, D. A. (2015). Essentials of Assessing, Preventing, and Overcoming Reading Difficulties. Wiley.

Stanovich, K. E. (2000). Progress in Understanding Reading: Scientific Foundations and New Frontiers. Guilford Press.

Goswami, U. (2002). Phonology, reading development, and dyslexia: A cross-linguistic perspective. Annals of Dyslexia, 52(1), 139-163.

Chat Soon-

PS: Here are 5 programs that address Phonemic awareness. These have been either recommended by researchers or educators. I only have personal experience with Heggerty and the OG approach. When adopting any program or materials, do your homework and make sure it addresses your concerns. I don't personally recommend or endorse any one program. 

• Heggerty Phonemic Awareness:  Developed by Dr. Michael Heggerty, this program offers daily lessons designed to build phonemic awareness in young learners. It's widely used in schools and praised for its structured, systematic approach.
• Jolly Phonics:  Jolly Phonics is a comprehensive program that includes phonemic awareness as a key component. It uses multi-sensory methods to teach children the five key skills for reading and writing.
• Orton-Gillingham Approach: Though not a standalone program, the Orton-Gillingham approach is a highly effective, evidence-based method for teaching phonemic awareness, particularly for students with dyslexia. It emphasizes direct, explicit, and multisensory instruction.
• Ladders to Literacy: This program, developed by the University of North Carolina, integrates phonemic awareness activities with other early literacy skills. It's research-based and designed to support young children in developing strong literacy foundations.
• Phonemic Awareness in Young Children: A Classroom Curriculum: Written by Marilyn Jager Adams and others, this curriculum provides a range of activities and lessons for teaching phonemic awareness. It's a widely respected resource among educators for its practical and research-based strategies.

Over the last four years, there has been a shift in how teachers teach reading. Many call it the "Reading Wars." But back in the 90s, data started to reshape the ideas of teaching reading. Data has always been around. It never went away. Many times it is just forgotten or seen as out of touch with what is really going on in the classroom. 

If we are to truly understand the shift from "Balanced Literacy" or "Whole Language" to the "Science of Reading" we have to understand where it restarted. 

In the late 1990s, the National Reading Panel (NRP) was convened by the U.S. Congress to evaluate the effectiveness of different approaches to teaching children how to read. The goal was to provide a clear, evidence-based understanding of the best practices in reading instruction. The resulting report, published in 2000, has profoundly impacted reading education in the United States and beyond.

The Formation and Mission of the National Reading Panel

The National Reading Panel was established in 1997 as part of the federal Reading Excellence Act. The panel comprised 14 members, including leading scientists in reading research, representatives of colleges of education, reading teachers, educational administrators, and parents. Their mission was to assess the effectiveness of various approaches to reading instruction by reviewing existing research studies.

Methodology

The NRP's methodology was rigorous and systematic. The panel focused on studies that met high standards of scientific research, including randomized control trials and other well-designed experiments. The panel reviewed over 100,000 studies conducted since 1966 and 10,000 earlier studies. Their review process culminated in the identification of five critical areas of reading instruction: phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and text comprehension.

Key Findings

Phonemic Awareness: Phonemic awareness is the ability to hear, identify, and manipulate individual sounds—phonemes—in spoken words. This skill is foundational for learning to read. The NRP found that teaching phonemic awareness significantly improves children’s reading skills, including word reading, reading comprehension, and spelling.

Phonics: Phonics instruction teaches the relationship between letters and sounds, enabling readers to decode words. The panel found that systematic and explicit phonics instruction is more effective than non-systematic or no phonics instruction. This approach is particularly beneficial for kindergarteners and first graders, as it helps them develop early reading skills that are crucial for later success.

Fluency: Reading fluency is the ability to read with speed, accuracy, and proper expression. The NRP highlighted the importance of guided oral reading practices in developing fluency. Students who read aloud with feedback and guidance from teachers, parents, or peers show significant improvements in reading fluency and overall reading achievement.

Vocabulary: A robust vocabulary is essential for reading comprehension. The NRP found that vocabulary should be taught both directly and indirectly. Direct vocabulary instruction involves teaching specific words, while indirect instruction involves exposing students to new words through reading and conversation. Both methods are necessary to help students understand and use new vocabulary in context.

Text Comprehension: Text comprehension is the ultimate goal of reading—it involves understanding and interpreting what is read. The NRP identified several strategies that improve comprehension, including:

• Monitoring comprehension: Teaching students to be aware of their understanding of the text.
• Using graphic organizers: Visual aids that help students organize and relate information from the text.
• Answering questions: Encouraging students to answer questions about the text to improve understanding.
• Generating questions: Teaching students to ask their own questions about the text.
• Summarizing: Helping students identify the main ideas and summarize the content.

Implications for Teaching

The findings of the National Reading Panel have significant implications for reading instruction. Here are some practical ways that educators can implement these findings in the classroom:

Balanced Literacy Programs: The NRP's findings support a balanced approach to literacy instruction, integrating various methods to address the five critical areas. Educators should provide systematic and explicit instruction in phonemic awareness and phonics, while also promoting fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension through diverse activities and reading materials.

Professional Development: Teachers need ongoing professional development to stay informed about the best practices in reading instruction. Training programs should focus on the five key areas identified by the NRP and provide teachers with practical strategies for implementing these in their classrooms.

Early Intervention:  Early identification and intervention for struggling readers are crucial. By addressing reading difficulties early, educators can prevent long-term reading problems. The NRP's findings underscore the importance of early instruction in phonemic awareness and phonics to build a strong foundation for future reading success.

Parental Involvement: Parents play a vital role in their children's reading development. Schools should encourage parents to engage in their children's reading activities and provide them with strategies to support reading at home. This can include reading aloud together, discussing books, and providing access to a variety of reading materials.

Use of Technology: Technology can be a valuable tool in reading instruction. Interactive software, e-books, and online resources can provide additional practice in phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension. Educators should integrate technology in a way that complements traditional teaching methods.

Criticisms and Controversies

While the National Reading Panel Report has been widely influential, it has also faced criticisms and controversies. Some educators and researchers argue that the panel's focus on certain methodologies, such as phonics, downplays other important aspects of reading instruction, such as whole language approaches and the role of motivation in reading. Additionally, some critics contend that the report's emphasis on quantitative research overlooks the insights that qualitative studies can provide.

Continuing Impact and Relevance

Despite these criticisms, the NRP Report remains a cornerstone of reading instruction policy and practice. Its influence is evident in the widespread adoption of balanced literacy programs and the emphasis on evidence-based teaching strategies. Furthermore, the report has spurred ongoing research into effective reading instruction, contributing to the evolving understanding of how children learn to read.

In recent years, the science of reading has continued to advance, building on the foundation laid by the NRP. New research has further explored the cognitive processes involved in reading, the impact of socio-economic factors on reading development, and the most effective ways to support diverse learners. Educators and policymakers continue to rely on the principles outlined in the NRP Report while adapting to new findings and changing educational contexts.

The National Reading Panel Report represents a pivotal moment in the field of reading education. Its comprehensive review of research provided a clear, evidence-based framework for effective reading instruction, emphasizing the importance of phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension. While it has faced criticisms, its impact on educational policy and practice is undeniable. As the science of reading continues to evolve, the NRP Report remains a valuable resource for educators, guiding the way toward more effective and inclusive reading instruction.

This is the beginning of a new series on the Science of Reading. The Science of Reading impacts how everyone including special education teachers teach reading to students regardless of their disability. The difference is the accommodations and modifications we make to help students access the material. 

Chat Soon-

References

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2000). Report of the National Reading Panel: Teaching Children to Read: An Evidence-Based Assessment of the Scientific Research Literature on Reading and Its Implications for Reading Instruction. U.S. Government Printing Office.

Shanahan, T. (2003). The National Reading Panel Report: Practical Advice for Teachers. Learning Point Associates.

Snow, C. E., Burns, M. S., & Griffin, P. (1998). Preventing Reading Difficulties in Young Children. National Academy Press.

The NRP Report's enduring legacy underscores the importance of rigorous, evidence-based approaches to reading instruction, ensuring that all children have the opportunity to become proficient and enthusiastic readers.